It’s Not Just About Substituting | The Paleo Diet®
noun_Search_345985 Created with Sketch.

Try The Paleo Diet®!

Learn more. Get recipes & meal plans. See the science.

It’s Not Just About Substituting

One of the negative consequences of The Paleo Diet’s® popularity is that many self-labeled experts have put an inaccurate spin on what constitutes “Paleo.” Too many inflammatory, low nutrient-density products are being labeled “Paleo” simply because they have substituted a non-Paleo ingredient with a “Paleo” ingredient. That’s not how the diet works.

Expand For More

So, you’re thinking about making a cake, but you want to stay “Paleo.” You think, I’ll just use almond flour. Not so fast. Replacing traditional flours or other non-Paleo ingredients with “Paleo-correct” substitutes is not eating Paleo. In fact, it directly contradicts the main tenet of The Paleo Diet: the belief that we eat like our hunter-gatherer ancestors. Do you think Paleolithic humans ate cake—of any kind?

Now, that's not to say that using almond or coconut flour is not a better option than using wheat flour, particularly if one has a gluten sensitivity. But you shouldn’t believe that the cake you’ve made is Paleo. It is still highly processed, low in nutrient-density and contributes to glycemic load. Worse, these substitute foods end up replacing healthy foods, such as clean animal protein and fresh fruits and vegetables, that provide the high nutrient density of a true Paleo Diet.

Eating a healthy Paleo Diet means we must change how we eat and get back to more basic, natural eating. Replacing sugar with honey and flour with coconut flour is not nature’s way.

So, does that mean you should never eat cake? Fortunately, we believe in an 85:15 approach, and encourage you to make 85 percent of your diet clean, true Paleo foods. This allows 15 percent to be some of the non-Paleo foods you enjoy. For most people, taking this approach will still provide the health benefits of adopting a modern Paleo Diet.

If the substitution of wheat flour for a nut flour is within the 15 percent, it is not an issue. Then you can feel good about improving the nutrition of your “Paleo-inspired” cake! Just accept that it’s part of your 15 percent. Don’t try to convince yourself its Paleo.

If, however, you have a health concern that persists after adopting an 85:15 Paleo Diet, you should consider an even greater compliance or try an elimination diet to find what non-Paleo foods trigger your condition. Autoimmune patients, for example, have demonstrated that 100 percent compliance is often required to stay in remission from their disease.

noun_chevron up_1746113 Created with Sketch.
How to Apply The Paleo Diet 85/15 Rule

Need more wiggle room in your diet? Try this categorized approach to dieting that will get you results while allowing you to enjoy your favorite off-limit foods.

By Mark J. Smith, Ph.D.
A Better Tasting Cookie and The Fall of The Roman Empire

In an age where Doritos and high fructose corn syrup mark the decline of healthy eating, is a better tasting cookie the benchmark of a great diet?

By Trevor Connor, M.S.
How to Be Paleo When You Can’t Eat Eggs

It’s hard to beat the nutritional powerhouse that are eggs, but as the second most recurrent food allergen they’re not for everyone. Find out what foods have similar nutritional profile’s for an easy substitute.

By Aimee McNew
Milking the Mylks: What’s the Best Option of the Plant-Based ‘Milks’?
Soy milk. Almond Milk. Hemp Milk. Coconut Milk. Oat Milk. Cow's milk is not part of the Paleo Diet, but which plant-based milk is best?
By Nell Stephenson
Arrowroot and Tapioca Flour: Are They Paleo?
Are Arrowroot and Tapioca flour Paleo alternatives to regular flour? See what the Founder of The Paleo Diet, Dr. Cordain, has to say!
By Loren Cordain, Ph.D.
Going Beyond the “Beyond Burger”: Do you really know what’s behind the craze and the glittery curtain?

The Beyond Meat burger is all the craze right now tasting like a real meat burger. But is it a Paleo option and most importantly is it healthy?

By Bill Manci
Nell's Corner: How Healthy are Those Healthy Snacks?

Non-GMO, gluten-free, low-fat - just how healthy are all those "healthy" labelled foods? At the Paleo Diet we believe in natural foods. Nell explains why.

By Nell Stephenson
Coconut milk – Is it the Paleo milk substitute?

Learn if coconut milk is a good milk substitute in the paleo diet. Browse The Paleo Diet® blog to learn more about paleo foods, paleo recipes & more!

By Nell Stephenson
Autism, Aspartame, and The Paleo Diet®

Guest writer Woodrow Monte writes about the impact of diet on autism - particularly the effects of substitutes like aspartame.

By Woodrow C. Monte, Ph.D.
Paleo Kosher, Paleo Halal, and Other Religious Dietary Restrictions

Religion came along well after the Paleolithic era ended. Can we follow The Paleo Diet and still adhere to kosher and other religioius dietary restrictions?

By Christopher Clark
Coconut Crackdown: Friend or Foe

Coconut oil is high in in a saturated fat called lauric acid. Does this make coconut oil bad for you? Or can it be healthy with the right diet?

By Loren Cordain, Ph.D.
Paleo Leadership
Trevor Connor
Trevor Connor

Dr. Loren Cordain’s final graduate student, Trevor Connor, M.S., brings more than a decade of nutrition and physiology expertise to spearhead the new Paleo Diet team.

Mark J Smith
Dr. Mark J. Smith

One of the original members of the Paleo movement, Mark J. Smith, Ph.D., has spent nearly 30 years advocating for the benefits of Paleo nutrition.

Nell Stephenson
Nell Stephenson

Ironman athlete, mom, author, and nutrition blogger Nell Stephenson has been an influential member of the Paleo movement for over a decade.

Loren Cordain
Dr. Loren Cordain

As a professor at Colorado State University, Dr. Loren Cordain developed The Paleo Diet® through decades of research and collaboration with fellow scientists around the world.