Fish Roe and Caviar: Paleo? Yes and No

Roe vs. caviar

I hate to split hairs, but a distinction must be made between roe and caviar. The commonly edible eggs of fish and other aquatic animals (sea urchins, squid, shrimp, lobster, scallops etc.) represent the mature ovaries of the females of these species. Roe, unlike chicken eggs, do not present themselves as a single distinct egg, but rather the eggs occur attached to one another in connective tissue called “skeins.”⁴ Roe skeins can be consumed in their raw (“green”) unadulterated state or processed in a manner that separates individual eggs from one another.

When salt is added to separated fish eggs (a procedure called “brining”) it yields a food product called “caviar” which may also be subject to other “curing” processes and added chemicals.⁴ In the U.S. only sturgeon caviar can be labeled as “caviar.”⁴ Other salted fish roe such as salmon must be labeled with the fish from which it was made. So, salted cured salmon roe becomes “salmon caviar.”⁴

Sturgeon caviar is one of the most expensive foods in the world with a one ounce (30 gram) tin costing between $50 and $75. High end Osetra sturgeon caviar runs about $12,000 a kilo or about $378 for an ounce. Surprisingly, much less expensive caviar from salmon, herring, squid and other species is nutritionally superior to sturgeon caviar, particularly in regard to omega 3 fatty acids.^{20, 34, 39, 40}

Salt and caviar

Any and all caviars are by definition manufactured using salt.⁴ Accordingly, these processed foods would have been unavailable for consumption to our pre-agricultural ancestors. However there is little doubt that fresh, “green” unadulterated fish roe would have been relished.

Below in Table 2, you can see that fresh, non-processed fish roe represents a very low dietary source of sodium, whereas caviar is a concentrated source of sodium because of its processing with salt (NaCl).

The USDA recommended limit for daily sodium intake is 2,300 mg. Caviar eggs whether from sturgeon, salmon, herring or other species typically is packaged in 1 oz. (30 g) or 50 g (1.76 oz.) tins, but can be purchased in higher bulk quantities. Accordingly, a single 1 oz. (30 g) tin of caviar (on low end estimates) delivers a whopping 450 mg of sodium, whereas on high end values, it is more devastating still at 1162 mg of sodium.

From table 2 above, you can see that if you are going to eat roe, a better strategy (sodium wise) would be to consume fresh or frozen fish eggs without added salt.

In the U.S. fresh roe (“green”) and frozen roe is considerably more difficult to obtain than salted caviar, but not impossible. Go online and you can see a substantial number of retailers offering unprocessed fresh or frozen roe without salt. So the bottom line with salted caviar is to eat it infrequently or as a treat – better yet eat non-salted roe if you can find it.

Taste test of three non-sturgeon caviars

As long as I am writing about the scientific merits or lack thereof caviar and fish roe, I thought that it might be useful for me to give you my taste test impressions of three caviars (whitefish, capelin, lumpfish) which I purchased from our local World Market store. Below are my taste impressions of these three items.

1. I started off my culinary caviar adventures with Pacific Plaza Imports “Golden Whitefish Caviar.”⁴⁷

I bought a 50 g tin of this roe for $6.99 and carefully read the label which indicated the following items and their respective order: wild pasteurized whitefish roe, natural caramel coloring, truffle oil, water, tragacanth gum (as a stabilizer), salt, sodium benzoate (as a preservative).

Whew! That’s quite a list of non-Paleo ingredients. The label tells us that this whitefish caviar is harvested from a species known as Coregonus clupeaformis. By contrasting the slightly lower sodium content of this roe to capelin and lumpfish (Table 2) from the same company, I was expecting that my taste test would be somewhat positive or at least better than the capelin and lumpfish taste tests. Yuck! What a disappointment.

I gingerly picked out a clump of black whitefish caviar from the 50 g tin with a small hors d’oeuvres fork. Immediately, upon hitting my mouth, this tiny amount of roe sickened me with its overpowering salty taste to the point that I wanted to spit it out. It didn’t taste like any food I have ever eaten, but rather more like putting pure salt crystals on my tongue, but perhaps worse.

The fish oil seemed to cause the processed roe salt to permeate my tongue in a greater manner than salt itself. This food was so excessively salty that I have little desire to ever again eat caviar. But waitFor this review, I had to sample capelin and lumpfish caviar which both contain considerably more salt than whitefish.

2. Lumpfish and Capelin Caviar.

I pop open the lids from the tins of both lumpfish and capelin caviar and prepare to dive into them with my hors d’oeuvres fork. After a brief taste (only a few caviar eggs of each), I simply cannot tolerate the overpowering salty queasiness this food brings on.

Therapeutic health benefits of fresh fish roe

Fish roes are one of the most concentrated food sources of long chain omega 3 fatty acids EPA (20:5n3) and DHA (22:6n3).^{3-5, 13, 14, 19, 20, 26, 28, 34, 38-40} In numerous animal experiments roe consumption has been shown to improve various markers of health and well being and to reduce morbidity and mortality.^{11, 21, 22, 33, 44, 46} Only a handful of human studies has evaluated roe consumption in regard to this food’s potential therapeutic health effects.^{3, 4} So, if you can find unsalted roe, it represents one of the best dietary sources of healthful long chain omega 3 fatty acids.

The long chain omega 3 fatty acids found in roe are different from these beneficial fatty acids that you my get if you take fish oil or fish oil capsules. The omega 3 fatty acids (DHA and EPA) in fish roe are contained in phospholipids (structural fat) whereas EPA and DHA in fish oil are contained in the triglyceride (storage fat) fraction.⁴⁸ A number of studies suggest that ingestion of EPA and DHA bound to phospholipids are more readily absorbed and better utilized than EPA and DHA bound to triglycerides.^{3, 48 - 52} Accordingly, some scientists propose that the omega 3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) found in fish eggs^{39, 48} and krill oil^{48, 50, 52} are more effective in enriching our bloodstream with these healthy nutrients. Unfortunately, few human experimental trials^{3, 50} have shown this proposed effect, and the best evidence to date indicates the “jury may still be out” on this concept because of experimental and methodological issues.^{8, 27}

Nevertheless, whether you consume fresh roe, krill oil, fish, fish oil, or fish oil capsules you will be doing your body a favor by ingesting long chain omega 3 fatty acids which reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer and other pro-inflammatory illnesses.

Fish roe lectins and allergy

When most people in the Paleo diet community see the word, “lectin” it typically conjures up images of plant foods such as whole grains and legumes which contain lectins such as wheat germ agglutinin (WGA in wheat) and phytohemagglutinin (PHA in beans).

In experimental animals, both of these lectins have been shown to bypass the gut barrier and promote adverse physiological effects.^{53, 54} To date, these lectins have been scarcely studied in human tissue (in vitro) experiments and almost never examined in living humans (in vivo studies).⁵⁵

Rarely do Paleo dieters recognize that certain animal foods may also contain various antinutrients, including lectins. Starting in the late 1970s, fish roe from most species was discovered to be a significant source of certain lectins.^56-59 As more recent work has confirmed, most fish roe lectins belong to a category of lectins called rhambose-binding lectins (RBLs).^{12, 16, 23, 32, 36, 37, 41, 42}

The biological function of RBLs in fish eggs seems to primarily involve activation of innate immunity, host pathogen interaction and inflammatory reactions in various fish tissues.^{32, 41, 42} Multiple RBLs (CSL1, 2 and 3) from chum salmon roe induced production of the pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-1 β1, IL-2β2, TNFα1 and IL-8) in fish macrophages.⁴² To date no experimental mammal, or human studies have determined if RBLs from fish roe interact with our immune systems to produce inflammation or undesired health effects.

However, substantial literature exists showing that fish roe consumption represents a common food allergen in humans, particularly children.^{7, 15, 24, 18, 29, 30, 31, 35} The primary allergen in fish roe is known as “ ß`- component”^{18, 29} and may cause severe anaphylactic reactions.

Conclusions

In the U.S., caviar is rarely eaten by the average consumer, whereas it is a common food item in Japan and other countries worldwide. Because caviar represents a concentrated salt source, it should be rarely consumed or avoided by regular Paleo dieters. If you can find it, fresh or frozen fish roe of any species represents one of the most concentrated dietary sources of the healthful, long chain, omega 3 fatty acids, EPA and DHA. Eat it if you can. However, if you experience an allergenic reaction – hives, itching skin, running nose, difficulty breathing, rashes, etc. – know that fish roe is a common dietary allergen, and the immunological flip side of allergy frequently involves autoimmunity.

References

[1]Al-Holy, M., Wang, Y., Tang, J., & Rasco, B. (2005). Dielectric properties of salmon (Oncorhynchus keta) and sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus) caviar at radio frequency (RF) and microwave (MW) pasteurization frequencies. Journal of Food Engineering, 70(4), 564-570.

[2]Al‐Holy , M. A., & Rasco, B. A. (2006). Characterization of salmon (Oncorhynchus keta) and sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus) caviar proteins. Journal of food biochemistry, 30(4), 422-428.

[3]Bjørndal, B., Strand, E., Gjerde, J., Bohov, P., Svardal, A., Diehl, B. W., ... & Berge, R. K. (2014). Phospholipids from herring roe improve plasma lipids and glucose tolerance in healthy, young adults. Lipids in health and disease, 13(1), 82.

[4]Bledsoe GE, Bledsoe CD, Rasco B. Caviars and fish roe products. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2003;43(3):317-56.

[5]Caprino F, Moretti VM, Bellagamba F, Turchini GM, Busetto ML, Giani I, Paleari MA, Pazzaglia M. Fatty acid composition and volatile compounds of caviar from farmed white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus). Anal Chim Acta. 2008 Jun 9;617(1-2):139-47.

[6]Chalamaiah M, Hemalatha R, Jyothirmayi T, Diwan PV, Bhaskarachary K, Vajreswari A, Ramesh Kumar R, Dinesh Kumar B. Chemical composition and immunomodulatory effects of enzymatic protein hydrolysates from common carp (Cyprinus carpio) egg. Nutrition. 2015 Feb;31(2):388-98.

[7]Fujita, S., Shimizu, Y., Kishimura, H., Watanabe, K., Hara, A., & Saeki, H. (2012). In vitro digestion of major allergen in salmon roe and its peptide portion with proteolytic resistance. Food Chemistry, 130(3), 644-650.

[8]Ghasemifard S, Turchini GM, Sinclair AJ. Omega-3 long chain fatty acid "bioavailability": a review of evidence and methodological considerations. Prog Lipid Res. 2014 Oct;56:92-108.

[9]Higuchi T, Shirai N, Suzuki H. Effects of dietary herring roe lipids on plasma lipid, glucose, insulin, and adiponectin concentrations in mice.J Agric Food Chem. 2006 May 17;54(10):3750-5.

[10]Higuchi T, Shirai N, Suzuki H. Effects of herring roe on plasma lipid, glucose, insulin and adiponectin levels, and hepatic lipid contents in mice. J Nutr Sci Vitaminol (Tokyo). 2008 Jun;54(3):230-6

[11]Higuchi T, Shirai N, Suzuki H. Effects of dietary herring roe lipids on plasma lipid, glucose, insulin, and adiponectin concentrations in mice. J Agric Food Chem. 2006 May 17;54(10):3750-5

[12]Hosono M, Kawauchi H, Nitta K, Takayanagi Y, Shiokawa H, Mineki R, Murayama K. Purification and characterization of Silurus asotus (catfish) roe lectin. Biol Pharm Bull. 1993 Jan;16(1):1-5.

[13]Intarasirisawat, R., Benjakul, S., & Visessanguan, W. (2011). Chemical compositions of the roes from skipjack, tongol and bonito. Food Chemistry, 124(4), 1328-1334.

[14]Kaitaranta JK, Linko RR. Fatty acids in the roe lipids of common food fishes. Comp Biochem Physiol B. 1984;79(3):331-4

[15]Kondo, Y., Kakami, M., Koyama, H., Yasuda, T., Nakajima, Y., Kawamura, M., ... & Urisu, A. (2005). IgE cross-reactivity between fish roe (salmon, herring and pollock) and chicken egg in patients anaphylactic to salmon roe. Allergology International, 54(2), 317-323.

[16]Lam YW, Ng TB. Purification and characterization of a rhamnose-binding lectin with immunoenhancing activity from grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idellus) ovaries.Protein Expr Purif. 2002 Dec;26(3):378-85.

[17]Ng TB, Lam YW, Woo NY. The immunostimulatory activity and stability of grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idellus) roe lectin. Vet Immunol Immunopathol. 2003 Aug 15;94(3-4):105-12.

[18]Liu, Y. Y., Cao, M. J., Zhang, M. L., Hu, J. W., Zhang, Y. X., Zhang, L. J., & Liu, G. M. (2014). Purification, characterization and immunoreactivity of β′-component, a major allergen from the roe of large yellow croaker (Pseudosciaena crocea). Food and Chemical Toxicology, 72, 111-121.

[19]Méndez, E., Fernández, M., Pazo, G., & Grompone, M. A. (1992). Hake roe lipids: composition and changes following cooking. Food chemistry, 45(3), 179-181.

[20]Mol S, Turan S. Comparison of proximate, fatty acid and amino acid compositions of various types of fish roes. Int J Food Properties . Volume 11, Issue 3, 2008, 669-677.

[21]Moriya H, Hosokawa M, Miyashita K. Combination effect of herring roe lipids and proteins on plasma lipids and abdominal fat weight of mouse. J Food Sci. 2007 Jun;72(5):C231-4.

[22]Moriya, H., Kuniminato, T., Hosokawa, M., Fukunaga, K., Nishiyama, T. , Miyashita, K. (2007), Oxidative stability of salmon and herring roe lipids and their dietary effect on plasma cholesterol levels of rats. Fisheries Science, 73: 668–674.

[23]Ogawa T, Watanabe M, Naganuma T, Muramoto K. Diversified carbohydrate-binding lectins from marine resources. J Amino Acids. 2011;2011:838914. doi: 10.4061/2011/838914.

[24]Perez-Gordo M, Sanchez-Garcia S, Cases B, Pastor C, Vivanco F, Cuesta-Herranz J. Identification of vitellogenin as an allergen in Beluga caviar allergy. Allergy. 2008 Apr;63(4):479-80.

[25]Rosa A, Scano P, Atzeri A, Deiana M, Falchi AM. Potential anti-tumor effects of Mugil cephalus processed roe extracts on colon cancer cells. Food Chem Toxicol. 2013 Oct;60:471-8.

[26]Rosa, A., Scano, P., Melis, M. P., Deiana, M., Atzeri, A., & Dessi, M. A. (2009). Oxidative stability of lipid components of mullet (Mugil cephalus) roe and its product “bottarga”. Food chemistry, 115(3), 891-896.

[27]Salem N Jr, Kuratko CN. A reexamination of krill oil bioavailability studies. Lipids Health Dis. 2014 Aug 26;13:137.

[28]Scano P, Rosa A, Cesare Marincola F, Locci E, Melis MP, Dessì MA, Lai A. 13C NMR, GC and HPLC characterization of lipid components of the salted and dried mullet (Mugil cephalus) roe "bottarga". Chem Phys Lipids. 2008 Feb;151(2):69-76

[29]Shimizu, Y., Oda, H., Seiki, K., & Saeki, H. (2015). Development of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay system for detecting β′-component (Onk k 5), a major IgE-binding protein in salmon roe. Food chemistry, 181, 310-317.

[30]Shimizu Y1, Kishimura H, Kanno G, Nakamura A, Adachi R, Akiyama H, Watanabe K, Hara A, Ebisawa M, Saeki H. Molecular and immunological characterization of β'-component (Onc k 5), a major IgE-binding protein in chum salmon roe. Int Immunol. 2014 Mar;26(3):139-47.

[31]Shimizu Y, Nakamura A, Kishimura H, Hara A, Watanabe K, Saeki H. Major allergen and its IgE cross-reactivity among salmonid fish roe allergy. J Agric Food Chem. 2009 Mar 25;57(6):2314-9.

[32]Shirai T, Watanabe Y, Lee MS, Ogawa T, Muramoto K. Structure of rhamnose-binding lectin CSL3: unique pseudo-tetrameric architecture of a pattern recognition protein. J Mol Biol. 2009 Aug 14;391(2):390-403.

[33]Shirai N, Higuchi T, Suzuki H. Effect of lipids extracted from a salted herring roe food product on maze-behavior in mice. J Nutr Sci Vitaminol (Tokyo). 2006 Dec;52(6):451-6

[34]Shirai, N., Higuchi, T., & Suzuki, H. (2006). Analysis of lipid classes and the fatty acid composition of the salted fish roe food products, Ikura, Tarako, Tobiko and Kazunoko. Food Chemistry, 94(1), 61-67.

[35]Tanaka K, Kondo Y, Inuo C, Nakajima Y, Tsuge I, Doi S, Yanagihara S, Yoshikawa T, Urisu A. Allergen analysis of sea urchin roe using sera from five patients. Int Arch Allergy Immunol. 2014;164(3):222-7

[36]Tateno H, Ogawa T, Muramoto K, Kamiya H, Saneyoshi M. Distribution and molecular evolution of rhamnose-binding lectins in Salmonidae: isolation and characterization of two lectins from white-spotted Charr (Salvelinus leucomaenis) eggs. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem. 2002 Jun;66(6):1356-65

[37]Terada T, Watanabe Y, Tateno H, Naganuma T, Ogawa T, Muramoto K, Kamiya H. Structural characterization of a rhamnose-binding glycoprotein (lectin) from Spanish mackerel (Scomberomorous niphonius) eggs. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2007 Apr;1770(4):617-29.

[38]Tocher DR, Sargent JR. Analyses of lipids and fatty acids in ripe roes of some Northwest European marine fish. Lipids. 1984 Jul;19(7):492-9.

[39]Wang, Q., Xue, C., Li, Z., & Xu, J. (2008). Analysis of DHA-rich phospholipids from egg of squid Sthenoteuthis oualaniensis. Journal of food composition and analysis, 21(4), 356-359.

[40]Wang, Q., Xue, Ch, Li, Z. J., & Xu, J. (2008). Phosphatidylcholine levels and their fatty acid compositions in squid egg: a comparison study with pollack roe and sturgeon caviar. Journal of Food Lipids, 15(2), 222-230.

[41]Watanabe Y, Shiina N, Shinozaki F, Yokoyama H, Kominami J, Nakamura-Tsuruta S, Hirabayashi J, Sugahara K, Kamiya H, Matsubara H, Ogawa T, Muramoto K. Isolation and characterization of l-rhamnose-binding lectin, which binds to microsporidian Glugea plecoglossi, from ayu (Plecoglossus altivelis) eggs. Dev Comp Immunol. 2008;32(5):487-99.

[42]Watanabe Y, Tateno H, Nakamura-Tsuruta S, Kominami J, Hirabayashi J, Nakamura O, Watanabe T, Kamiya H, Naganuma T, Ogawa T, Naudé RJ, Muramoto K. The function of rhamnose-binding lectin in innate immunity by restricted binding to Gb3. Dev Comp Immunol. 2009 Feb;33(2):187-97.

[43]//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe

[44]Shirai N, Higuchi T, Suzuki, H. A comparative study of lipids extracted from herring roe products and fish oil on plasma glucose and adipocytokine levels in ICR aged mice. Food Science and Technology Research, Vol. 14 (2008) No. 1, 25-31

[45]Nutritionist Pro Software, Version 4.7.0. Axxya Systems LLC. Redmond WA. //www.nutritionistpro.com/

[46]Bjørndal B, Burri L, Wergedahl H, Svardal A, Bohov P, Berge RK. Dietary supplementation of herring roe and milt enhances hepatic fatty acid catabolism in female mice transgenic for hTNFα. Eur J Nutr. 2012 Sep;51(6):741-53

[47]Pacific Plaza Imports Caviar label information. 1) Golden Whitefish Caviar, 2) Black Lumpfish Roe, 3) Black Capelin Roe. www.plazadecaviar.com

[48]Burri L, Hoem N, Banni S, Berge K. Marine omega-3 phospholipids: metabolism and biological activities. Int J Mol Sci. 2012 Nov 21;13(11):15401-19.

[49]Murru E, Banni S, Carta G. Nutritional properties of dietary omega-3-enriched phospholipids. Biomed Res Int. 2013;2013:965417. doi: 10.1155/2013/965417

[50]Ramprasath VR, Eyal I, Zchut S, Jones PJ. Enhanced increase of omega-3 index in healthy individuals with response to 4-week n-3 fatty acid supplementation from krill oil versus fish oil. Lipids Health Dis. 2013 Dec 5;12:178. doi: 10.1186/1476-511X-12-178.

[51]Rossmeisl M, Jilkova ZM, Kuda O, et al. Metabolic effects of n-3 PUFA as phospholipids are superior to triglycerides in mice fed a high-fat diet: possible role of endocannabinoids. PLoS One. 2012;7(6):e38834.

[52]Schuchardt JP, Schneider I, Meyer H, Neubronner J, von Schacky C, Hahn A. Incorporation of EPA and DHA into plasma phospholipids in response to different omega-3 fatty acid formulations--a comparative bioavailability study of fish oil vs. krill oil. Lipids Health Dis. 2011 Aug 22;10:145. doi: 10.1186/1476-511X-10-145.

[53]Cordain L. (1999). Cereal grains: humanity’s double edged sword. World Review of Nutrition and Dietetics, 84: 19-73.

[54]Cordain L, Toohey L, Smith MJ, Hickey MS. Modulation of immune function by dietary lectins in rheumatoid arthritis. British Journal of Nutrition, 2000, 83:207-217.

[55]Kuzma JN, Cordain L. Ingestion of wheat germ in healthy subjects does not acutely elevate plasma wheat germ agglutinin concentrations. FASEB J 2010, 24:723.10 .

[56]Krajhanzl A, Horejsí V, Kocourek J.Studies on lectins. XLI. Isolation and characterization of a blood group B specific lectin from the role of the powan (Coregonus lavaretus maraena). Biochim Biophys Acta. 1978 Feb 15;532(2):209-14.

[57]Krajhanzl A, Horejsí V, Kocourek J. Studies on lectins. XLII. Isolation, partial characterization and comparison of lectins from the roe of five fish species. Biochim Biophys Acta. 1978 Feb 15;532(2):215-24.

[58]Nosek J, Krajhanzl A, Kocourek J. Studies on lectins. LVII. Immunofluorescence localization of lectins present in fish ovaries. Histochemistry. 1983;79(1):131-9.

[59]Krajhanzl A. Egg lectins of invertebrates and lower vertebrates: properties and biological function. Adv Lectin Res 1990; 3: 83-131.